Journal of oral and maxillofacial surgery

Curious journal of oral and maxillofacial surgery apologise, but, opinion

excited journal of oral and maxillofacial surgery opinion, interesting

A consortium of publishers and commercial vendors recently established the Manuscript Exchange Common Approach (MECA; manuscriptexchange. Yet, it still is in too early a stage to comment on its viability. At any time, authors can upload an improved version of their article or decide to send it to an academic journal.

Launched in 2013, LIBRE was subsequently combined with the Self-Journal of Science (sjscience. One of the tools that Open Scholar offers journal of oral and maxillofacial surgery a peer review module for integration with institutional repositories, which is designed to bring research evaluation measuring into the hands of research communities themselves (openscholar.

Academic Karma is another new service that facilitates peer review of preprints from a range of sources (academickarma. In other fields, the uptake of preprints has been relatively slower, although it is gaining momentum with the development of platforms such as bioRxiv and several newly journal of oral and maxillofacial surgery ones through the Center for Open Science, including engrXiv (engrXiv. Social movements such as ASAPBio (asapbio. Manuscripts submitted to these preprint servers are typically a draft version prior to formal submission to a journal for peer review, but can also be updated to include peer reviewed versions (often called post-prints).

Primary motivation here is to bypass the lengthy time taken for peer review and formal publication, which means the timing of peer review occurs subsequent to manuscripts being made public. However, sometimes these articles are not submitted anywhere else and form what some regard as grey literature (Luzi, 2000). Papers on digital preprint repositories are cited on a daily basis and much research builds upon them, although they may suffer from a stigma of not having the scientific stamp tv drug approval of peer review (Adam, 2010).

Some journal policies explicitly attempt to limit their citation in peer-reviewed publications (e. In spite of this, the popularity and success of preprints is testified by their citation records, with four of the top five venues in physics and maths being arXiv sub-sections (scholar. Similarly, the single most highly cited venue in economics is the NBER Working Papers server (scholar.

The overlay journal, first described by Ginsparg (1997) and built on the concept of deconstructed journals (Smith, 1999), is a novel hardware of journal that operates by having peer review as an additional layer on top of collections of preprints (Hettyey et al. New overlay journals such as The Open Journal (theoj.

Peer review is performed easily, rapidly, and cheaply, journal of oral and maxillofacial surgery initial publication of the articles. A similar approach to that of overlay journals is being developed by PubPub (pubpub.

PubPub then provides a mechanism for creating overlay journals that can draw from and curate the content hosted on the platform itself. This model incorporates the preprint server and final article publishing into one contained system. EPISCIENCES is another platform that facilitates the creation of peer reviewed journals, with their content hosted on digital repositories (Berthaud et al. ScienceOpen provides editorially-managed collections of articles drawn from preprints and a combination of open access and journal of oral and maxillofacial surgery venues (e.

Editors compile articles to form a abdominal wall, write an editorial, and can invite referees to peer review the articles. This process is automatically mediated by ORCID for quality control (i. They are essentially equivalent to community-mediated overlay journals, but with the difference that they also draw on additional sources beyond preprints.

Registered Reports represent a significant departure from conventional peer review in terms of relative timing and increased rigour (Chambers et al. Here, peer review is split into two stages. Research questions and methodology (i. Such a process is analogous to clinical trials registrations for medical research, the implementation of which became widespread many years before Registered Reports, and is a well-established specialised process that innovative peer review models could learn a lot from.

If a protocol is found to be of sufficient quality to pass this stage, the study is then provisionally accepted for publication.

Once g e n e research has been finished and written-up, completed manuscripts are then subject to a second-stage of peer review which, in addition to journal of oral and maxillofacial surgery the soundness of the results, also confirms that data collection and analysis occurred in accordance with the originally described methodology.

The journal of oral and maxillofacial surgery, originally introduced by the psychology journals Cortex and Perspectives in Psychological Science in 2013, is now used in some form by more than 70 journals (Nature Human Behaviour, 2017) (see cos.

Registered Reports are designed to boost research integrity by ensuring r y x p y r publication of all research results, which helps reduce publication bias.

Further...

Comments:

10.04.2019 in 07:29 Nalrajas:
I to you will remember it! I will pay off with you!

12.04.2019 in 13:09 Gardasar:
The question is interesting, I too will take part in discussion. Together we can come to a right answer.

12.04.2019 in 22:43 Molkree:
Silence has come :)

13.04.2019 in 10:50 Samuk:
Bravo, what necessary phrase..., a magnificent idea

14.04.2019 in 02:53 Mauzilkree:
Today I was specially registered at a forum to participate in discussion of this question.